Home›Ohio›Trumbull County›SHEPHERD OF THE VALLEY LIBERTY
B
Good

SHEPHERD OF THE VALLEY LIBERTY

1501 TIBBETTS WICK ROAD · GIRARD, OH 44420

3305440771 · Non profit - Church related

79 beds64 residents330 staff
CMS Five-Star Ratings
Overall
★★★★★
Staffing
★★★★★
Quality
★★★★★
Inspections
★★★★★
Staffing Grades
A
Very Good
Total Staff
B
Good
RN Staff
B
Good
Overall
✓CMS Benchmark(≥ 3.48 HPRD)
✗RN Recommendation(≥ 0.75 HPRD)
✓Research Standard(≥ 4.10 HPRD)
📋

What This Means in Plain English

SHEPHERD OF THE VALLEY LIBERTY receives an overall staffing grade of B (Good). With 4.4509 total nurse hours per resident per day, this facility meets the CMS staffing benchmark and has RN staffing of 0.7232 HPRD, below the recommended 0.75. It is 0.55 HPRD above the national average.

Weekend staffing decreases noticeably — dropping 19.3% compared to weekdays. The facility relies heavily on temporary agency staff (23.93% of hours), suggesting potential workforce instability.

Staffing levels have been trending upward over recent quarters.

🔍 Areas of Concern (2)

⚠️RN staffing (0.7232 HPRD) is below the research-recommended minimum of 0.75 HPRD. This means less clinical oversight per resident.
⚠️23.93% of nursing hours come from agency/contract workers. High contractor reliance often means less continuity of care — staff who don't know the residents.

✨ Strengths (2)

✅Meets the CMS staffing benchmark (≥ 3.48 HPRD)
✅No days with zero registered nurse hours this quarter
Total Nurse HPRD
4.4509hrs/resident/day▲ 0.55
CMS benchmark: 3.48
RN HPRD
0.7232hrs/resident/day▲ 0.04
Recommended: 0.75
Weekend Drop-off
19.3%
4.7077 weekday → 3.799 weekend
Agency Staff
23.93%
0.06% of RN hours from contractors
⚠ High contractor reliance
Days with Zero RN
0days this quarter
4+ days = auto 1-star
CNA HPRD
2.3695hrs/resident/day
Direct care aides
LPN HPRD
1.3582hrs/resident/day
Licensed practical nurses
Consistency
0.5222std dev
Lower = more predictable

HPRD Over Time

Total nurse staffing hours per resident per day, by quarter

Total HPRD (shaded area)RN HPRDCMS Benchmark (3.48) — staffing standardResearch Standard (4.10) — recommended level

How Does This Facility Compare?

Compared to county, state, and national averages for total nurse HPRD

vs. Trumbull County Average+0.72 HPRD
3.73
04.45 HPRD
vs. Ohio State Average+0.72 HPRD
3.73
04.45 HPRD
vs. National Average+0.55 HPRD
3.90
04.45 HPRD
■ Colored bar = this facility · | Black line = average · Based on 2025Q3 data

Nearby Facilities

Compare with other nursing homes in the area

FacilityDistanceGradeTotal HPRDRN HPRDCMS Rating
SHEPHERD OF THE VALLEY LIBERTY ★
GIRARD · This facility
—
B
4.45090.7232★★★☆☆
HERITAGE MANOR JEWISH HM FOR
YOUNGSTOWN
3.6 mi
A
4.6260.8117★★★★★
WINDSOR HEALTH CARE CENTER
YOUNGSTOWN
4.3 mi
C
3.56050.5401★★★★★
OMNI MANOR NURSING HOME
YOUNGSTOWN
4.9 mi
C
3.5090.4385★★★☆☆
PARK VISTA NURSING AND REHAB
YOUNGSTOWN
4.9 mi
C
3.22960.6261★☆☆☆☆
COMMUNITY SKILLED HEALTHCARE
WARREN
9 mi
C
4.32930.4084★☆☆☆☆

Inspection History & Penalties

Health inspection results from state surveys — most recent first

4
Inspections
18
Total Deficiencies
$0
Fines Assessed
Sep 22, 2025Health
8 deficiencies cited
▼
May 21, 2025Health
1 deficiency cited
▼
Oct 5, 2023Health
6 deficiencies cited· Includes actual harm
▼
Jul 29, 2021Health
3 deficiencies cited
▼
CMS Severity Scale
A–C: No Harm / PotentialD–F: No Harm but ConcernG–H: Actual HarmI–L: Immediate Jeopardy

Source: CMS Staffing & Quality Data — 2025Q3 · data.cms.gov

Staffing grades are based on CMS-published thresholds and research recommendations. CMS is not affiliated with and does not endorse this website.